Carfax Used Car Index: Is it Time to Buy a Used Hybrid or EV? Do the Math First
We’ve talked about it before, but the average asking price for used Hybrids & Electric Vehicles (EVs) continues to drop. As we’ve noted, it’s largely due to many coming off of leases that began in 2023, when there were additional incentives. That increased inventory supply is outstripping demand and, across all Hybrid and EV models, the average asking price on Carfax dropped more than $230 in October.
But there’s a caveat: With gas prices remaining high because of the war with Iran, some used Hybrids and EVs are selling for more than new 2026 models. In these cases, buying the used version is not as good a deal. Some examples:
Used Toyota RAV4 Hybrid SUVs are selling on average for nearly $49,000 on Carfax. The starting price for 2026 models — all have a hybrid powertrain — range from roughly $32,000 up to $43,000 for a top-of-the-line trim. (Be aware, though: Right now, it’s kind of difficult to even find a new 2026 RAV4)
Used Lexus RX500H SUVs have an average asking price north of $72,000. Its base MSRP is roughly $58,000.
The Ford Maverick bucks that trend, but only slightly. The average used asking price for the Maverick with a hybrid powertrain on Carfax is right at $38,000; the starting MSRP for a new 2026 Lariat trim with a hybrid powertrain is just 95 bucks more. That’s a coin toss, but the new model does come with a full warranty and other new-car perks.
There are dozens of used hybrids for sale right now. Do your research and you’ll not only save money on gas, but maybe on the vehicle itself too.
On the flip side, family haulers broke new ground this month — and not in a good way. The average price of used SUVs on Carfax topped $25,000 for the first time in the history of the Used Car Index. And the average price of used Vans & Minivans topped $24,000 for the first time ever too.
Overall, though, it was a totally flat month for the Index. The average increase in price was just 0.1%, or about 2 bucks.

National Used Car Price Trends
Prices were mixed on Carfax.com in October:
As noted above, the average price for used Hybrids & EVs on Carfax fell by more than $230.
Not too far behind, the average price of used Luxury SUVs dropped by more than $180.
Also in the “prices are falling” category are used Pickup Trucks, whose average fell by more than $80.
The average asking price of Used Cars (sedans, hatchbacks, wagons, etc.) rose a little more than $80.
Used Luxury Cars continued their price hikes, rising more than $120 in a month.
Next were used Vans & Minivans, whose average asking price climbed by nearly $150.
Finally, the average price of used SUVs rose by nearly $170.
Regional Trends
Here’s what’s going on in each of our regions this month:
Mid-Atlantic (PA, NJ, MD, DE)
Used prices were mixed:
Segment with the biggest price increase: Used Vans & Minivans, up more than $270.
Segment with the biggest price drop: Used Hybrids & EVs, down more than $500.
Midwest (OH, IN, MI, IL, WI, MN, IA, MO)
Used prices were mixed:
Segment with the biggest price increase: Used Vans & Minivans, up more than $300.
Segment with the biggest price drop: Used Hybrids & EVs, down about $230.
Northeast (NY, CT, VT, NH, ME, RI, MA)
Used prices were mixed:
Segment with the biggest price increase: Used Luxury Cars, up nearly $400.
Segment with the biggest price drop: Used Hybrids & EVs, down nearly $800.
Plains (OK, ND, SD, NE, KS, ID, WY, MT)
Used prices were mixed:
Segment with the biggest price increase: Used Vans & Minivans, up more than $150.
Segment with the biggest price drop: Used Luxury Cars, down more than $1,650!
South (GA, FL, AL, MS, LA, AR)
Used prices were mixed:
Segment with the biggest price increase: Used Cars, up more than $370.
Segment with the biggest price drop: Used Hybrids & EVs, down more than $340.
Southeast (VA, WV, NC, SC, KY, TN)
Used prices were mixed:
Segment with the biggest price increase: Used Vans & Minivans, up only about $65.
Segment with the biggest price drop: Used Hybrids & EVs, down more than $700.
Southwest (UT, CO, AZ, NM, TX)
Used prices were mixed:
Segment with the biggest price increase: Used Vans & Minivans, up by more than $400.
Segments with the biggest price drops: Used Hybrids & EVs and used Luxury SUVs, both down by more than $400.
West (WA, CA, OR, NV, HI, AK)
All used segments saw higher prices this month:
Segment with the biggest price increase: Used Luxury Cars, up by nearly $800.
Segment with the lowest price increase: Used Hybrids & EVs, up by nearly $150.
Is Now a Good Time to Buy a Used Vehicle?
Carfax data shows most used-car prices remain high. On the bright side, when used-car prices go up, so typically do used-car values for owners looking to sell. To cash in, it’s important to know how much your trade-in is really worth: Check your car’s value with the Carfax History-Based Value tool. SUVs and pickup trucks remain popular; sellers can get good money for those.
Of course, before you buy any car, do your research to get the latest information on pricing and deals. And be flexible. Keeping an open mind about models and manufacturers will provide you with more financial options. Due diligence can help you get the car you need for a fair price.
How Does Damage Affect Used Car Prices?
The Carfax Used Car Index also looks at the average discount baked into cars with major or minor damage. For vehicles with minor damage, the drop in value can be measured in hundreds of dollars. For vehicles with major damage, the effect can be 10 times greater – or more. Many shoppers will avoid cars with damage, but they can be a good deal, provided they have been repaired well. Models with properly repaired cosmetic damage can cost less than cars without any damage in their history. Carfax’s used car listings come with a free Carfax Report that shows damage history. Of course, as with any used-car purchase, shoppers should have a trusted mechanic check out the car before buying.
How We Compile This Index
The Carfax Used Car Index compares the average price of a segment’s listings on Carfax.com. It also shows a trend line for the most recent 12 months. The index tracks vehicle prices in each of these seven segments:




