Atlantic Toyota

4.4
New Car Sales: (631) 529-4780Used Car Sales: (631) 769-2773Service: (631) 693-5137
Sales Open until 6:00 PM
Service Open until 4:00 PM
193 Sunrise Hwy North Service Rd West Islip, NY 11795
Website

Atlantic Toyota

4.4
Sales Open until 6:00 PM
Service Open until 4:00 PM
Website

229 New and Used Vehicles for Sale at Atlantic Toyota

Every used car comes with a FREE CARFAX Report
Sort by: CARFAX Best Match
1 - 12 of 229 results
2019 Toyota Avalon Limited Edition
Used 2019 Toyota Avalon Limited Edition
$29,000 | 14,916 miles
great value
$2,110 below CARFAX Value
No Accident or Damage Reported
No Accident or Damage Reported
Personal Use
Personal Use
CARFAX 1-Owner
CARFAX 1-Owner
Service History
17 Service History Records
2023 Toyota RAV4 XLE
Toyota Certified Pre-Owned
Used 2023 Toyota RAV4 XLE
$28,995 | 31,010 miles
great value
$1,825 below CARFAX Value
No Accident or Damage Reported
No Accident or Damage Reported
Personal Use
Personal Use
CARFAX 1-Owner
CARFAX 1-Owner
Service History
9 Service History Records
2022 Toyota Tacoma TRD Off Road
Toyota Certified Pre-Owned
Used 2022 Toyota Tacoma TRD Off Road
$36,499 | 31,280 miles
great value
$1,911 below CARFAX Value
No Accident or Damage Reported
No Accident or Damage Reported
Personal Use
Personal Use
2-Owner
2-Owner
Service History
10 Service History Records
2022 Toyota RAV4 XSE
Toyota Certified Pre-Owned
Used 2022 Toyota RAV4 XSE
$34,995 | 52,263 miles
great value
$1,505 below CARFAX Value
Accident Reported
Accident Reported
Personal Use
Personal Use
CARFAX 1-Owner
CARFAX 1-Owner
Service History
16 Service History Records
2024 Toyota RAV4 LE
Toyota Certified Pre-Owned
Used 2024 Toyota RAV4 LE
$28,995 | 15,640 miles
good value
$1,025 below CARFAX Value
No Accident or Damage Reported
No Accident or Damage Reported
Personal Use
Personal Use
CARFAX 1-Owner
CARFAX 1-Owner
Service History
7 Service History Records
2018 Toyota RAV4 LE
Used 2018 Toyota RAV4 LE
$19,995 | 49,018 miles
good value
$195 below CARFAX Value
No Accident or Damage Reported
No Accident or Damage Reported
Personal Use
Personal Use
2-Owner
2-Owner
Service History
19 Service History Records
2024 Toyota Corolla Cross Nightshade
Toyota Certified Pre-Owned
Used 2024 Toyota Corolla Cross Nightshade
$31,995 | 9,046 miles
fair value
$365 above CARFAX Value
No Accident or Damage Reported
No Accident or Damage Reported
Personal Use
Personal Use
CARFAX 1-Owner
CARFAX 1-Owner
Service History
5 Service History Records
2017 Toyota Corolla iM Base
Used 2017 Toyota Corolla iM Base
$11,995 | 94,088 miles
great value
$1,595 below CARFAX Value
No Accident or Damage Reported
No Accident or Damage Reported
Personal Use
Personal Use
3+ Owners
3+ Owners
Service History
18 Service History Records
2025 Toyota Grand Highlander LE
Used 2025 Toyota Grand Highlander LE
$41,995 | 5,962 miles
good value
$865 below CARFAX Value
No Accident or Damage Reported
No Accident or Damage Reported
Personal Use
Personal Use
CARFAX 1-Owner
CARFAX 1-Owner
Service History
4 Service History Records
2023 Toyota RAV4 LE
Toyota Certified Pre-Owned
Used 2023 Toyota RAV4 LE
$27,995 | 28,765 miles
good value
$185 below CARFAX Value
No Accident or Damage Reported
No Accident or Damage Reported
Personal Use
Personal Use
CARFAX 1-Owner
CARFAX 1-Owner
Service History
6 Service History Records
2022 Toyota RAV4 LE
Toyota Certified Pre-Owned
Used 2022 Toyota RAV4 LE
$26,987 | 25,423 miles
good value
$493 below CARFAX Value
Minor Damage
Minor Damage
Personal Use
Personal Use
CARFAX 1-Owner
CARFAX 1-Owner
Service History
10 Service History Records
2022 Toyota Highlander XLE
Toyota Certified Pre-Owned
Used 2022 Toyota Highlander XLE
$39,995 | 24,724 miles
good value
$245 below CARFAX Value
No Accident or Damage Reported
No Accident or Damage Reported
Personal Use
Personal Use
CARFAX 1-Owner
CARFAX 1-Owner
Service History
14 Service History Records
1 - 12 of 229 results

Sell Your Car with CARFAX in 3 Easy Steps!

Ratings & Reviews

Overall Rating
4.4
392 Verified Reviews
5 Star
77%
4 Star
8%
3 Star
4%
2 Star
2%
1 Star
9%
Sort by: Most Helpful
Read reviews that mention
by 2025 TOYOTA PRIUS SE/XSE/XSE PREMIUM Owner on 11/18/2025Verified Service
I was treated like im just asking for a favor and not a customer plues service and parts is a really a joke , make me drive saying they have the parts when i got there , no parts . Like im Not paying my money. Dealer told me will call me back to see if the part needs to be repaired did not call me until 1 pm plus schedule for whenever they feel like .
by 2015 TOYOTA RAV4 LTD Owner on 08/15/2025Verified Service
Went in with no issues looking for an inspection. Magically my check engine light came on. Then they don't let you pay with a credit card without adding a 3% surcharge. You can pay by check but the check machine never accepts any checks! Nickle and diming not a good look.
by Angel J H. on 06/09/2025Verified Service
I like how they helped me through the process to do the service also went they found the problem they was honest and told me I can ride my car and bring back later because the parts was back order or I can get a lonner car at no cost that was nice and helpful through the whole process. Thanks Kile for your help
by 2018 TOYOTA CAMRY XSE/XLE Owner on 03/10/2025Verified Service
I bought my car less than 2 months ago and when I started my car in the morning all the warning lights were on, I got scared and made an appointment with the service. Even though it had a full 5 year warranty, they said they only looked at the car and there was nothing wrong and want me 210 dollars. You can't know what happened without looking at the car and I don't want to pay extra money for a car with a warranty.
by 2017 TOYOTA CAMRY LE/XLE/SE/XSE Shopper on 01/18/2025Verified Purchase
I purchased a used Toyota Camry for $18,000 and made a $2,000 down payment. Today, I saw on my bank statement that the loan principal is $20,000, and the total amount I'll have to pay in the end will exceed $30,000. The sales consultant is not answering my calls or returning my messages.
by 2025 TOYOTA TACOMA DOUBLE CAB/SR5/TRD Owner on 11/20/2025Verified Service
My first service after purchase, mentioned some issues but those guys didnt reeally care. Weird place
by Chenits@optimum N. on 10/16/2025Verified Purchase
My salesperson, Will Blackwood was extremely knowledgeable and made my experience virtually stress free. Thank you, Will.
by Shinobispirits@aol C. on 09/28/2025Verified Service
Realized car has two tires with bubbles- sold to me that way. Brake pedal slips- mentioned it and it's still happening
by 2024 TOYOTA RAV4 XLE/WOODLAND EDITION Owner on 09/27/2025Verified Service
Mike was unbelievably Pleasant to work with as he gave me all the details of my service and future services.
by 2025 TOYOTA RAV4 XLE PREMIUM Shopper on 08/14/2025Verified Purchase
Lynn Vanegas was terrific. Our third car from her. We were in and out in 1-1/2 hours because of her.
by 2020 TOYOTA C-HR XLE/LE/LIMITED Owner on 08/05/2025Verified Service
I love working with Tasha, she's amazing and always keeps you in the loop. I do feel, at times, that I'm being sold a product &/or service that I don't necessarily need.
by 2024 TOYOTA COROLLA CROSS LE Owner on 07/01/2025Verified Service
They always take my car on time. The service reps are great at keeping me updated on the car's progress.
by Schleisnerj@gmail C. on 06/25/2025Verified Service
The car was fixed quickly, but I never got a straight answer as to what was wrong with it. When I asked I got a nonsense answer.
by 2023 TOYOTA RAV4 XLE/WOODLAND EDITION Owner on 05/31/2025Verified Service
Promptly greeted and met with service advisor immediately Work was done promptly and at agreed price. Very Satisfied
by 2021 TOYOTA RAV4 LE Owner on 05/31/2025Verified Service
The service and people were great. My maintenance light was never reset after service so it keeps coming up.
by 2022 TOYOTA AVALON XLE Owner on 05/16/2025Verified Service
My experience with Atlantic Toyota was fine, the car is excellent, my sales rep was clear and concise with all the details and answering my questions.
by 2021 TOYOTA COROLLA LE Owner on 04/24/2025Verified Service
Service Representative Michael was amazing, I will go anywhere he goes!! Great ambassador for the company and dealership
by 2015 TOYOTA SIENNA SPORT Owner on 03/23/2025Verified Service
Well after two hours wait know one came to tell me anything I had to walk back over to customer service and ask how much longer
by 2019 TOYOTA HIGHLANDER SE/XLE Owner on 03/03/2025Verified Service
$180 for a oil change and tire rotation is robbery. I love my car very much but I don't love being robbed either. Cold day in heck before they see me again
by 2024 TOYOTA COROLLA CROSS L Owner on 03/02/2025Verified Service
My car was NOT serviced at Atlantic Toyota on 2/18/25! Please tell me how this happened. Please adjust Carfax report for my car. Thank you
1 - 20 of 392 results

Service Information

Don't miss your service!

Schedule or call your dealer for service appointment today to avoid costly repair cost.

3,965 Customer Favorites

Customers who favorite a shop get free open recall alerts, service reminders, vehicle service history, & more!

Top Services Performed

Based on CARFAX Service History, Atlantic Toyota specializes in these services, in addition to many others.

  • Auto Maintenance
  • Battery Service
  • Brake Service
  • Check Engine Light Diagnosis
  • Electrical Repair
  • Emissions Inspection
  • Engine Service & Repair
  • Exhaust
  • Full Service Auto Repair
  • Mechanical Repair
  • Muffler Repair
  • Oil Change
  • Safety Inspection
  • Steering & Suspension
  • Tire Rotation
  • Tire Service & Repair
  • Transmission Service & Repair
  • Wheel Alignment

Top Makes Serviced

Based on CARFAX Service History, Atlantic Toyota specializes in these makes, in addition to many others.

  • Chevrolet Services
    Chevrolet
  • Honda Services
    Honda
  • Lexus Services
    Lexus
  • Mazda Services
    Mazda
  • Toyota Services
    Toyota

Shop Amenities

  • Complimentary Drinks
  • Courtesy Shuttle
  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Kid's Playroom
  • Mobile Charging Station
  • Quiet Room

About Us

Get In Touch
Sales Information
New Car Sales: (631) 529-4780
Used Car Sales: (631) 769-2773
Today: Open until 6:00 PM
Sunday
11:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Monday
9:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Tuesday
9:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Wednesday
9:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Thursday
9:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Friday
9:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Saturday
9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
193 Sunrise Hwy North Service Rd West Islip, NY 11795
Service Information
Service: (631) 693-5137
Today: Open until 4:00 PM
Sunday
Closed
Monday
7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Tuesday
7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday
7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday
7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday
7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Saturday
7:30 AM - 4:00 PM
193 Sunrise Hwy North Service Rd West Islip, NY 11795

Frequently Asked Questions

What do verified customers think about Atlantic Toyota in West Islip, NY? Verified customers who visit Atlantic Toyota in West Islip, NY rate this business 4.4 out of 5 stars, with 392 reviews. 3,965 customers favorited this location.
How can I contact Atlantic Toyota in West Islip, NY? To reach the sales team at Atlantic Toyota in West Islip, NY, call (631) 769-2773. To reach the service department, call (631) 693-5137
How can I schedule a service appointment with Atlantic Toyota in West Islip, NY? You can schedule a service appointment at Atlantic Toyota in West Islip, NY through CARFAX.
What are the shop amenities offered by Atlantic Toyota in West Islip, NY? Atlantic Toyota in West Islip, NY offers the following amenities: Complimentary Drinks, Courtesy Shuttle, Free Wi-Fi, Kid's Playroom, Mobile Charging Station and Quiet Room.
Does Atlantic Toyota in West Islip, NY have a service center? Yes, Atlantic Toyota in West Islip, NY does have a service center. You can contact the service department at (631) 693-5137.