First Choice Auto

4.3

Car Sales: (845) 622-5816

Sales Closed until 10:00 AM

More Hours

1544 Route 22 Wingdale, NY 12594

Website

Call

Website

Every used car comes with a FREE CARFAX Report

1 - 12 of 32 results

Used 2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i

$9,595 | 140,923 miles

great value

No Accident or Damage Reported

Personal Use

CARFAX 1-Owner

1 Service History Record

Used 2012 Mazda Mazda3 i Sport

$5,795 | 139,258 miles

great value

No Accident or Damage Reported

Personal Use

CARFAX 1-Owner

7 Service History Records

Used 2016 Jeep Renegade Latitude

$7,995 | 138,341 miles

great value

No Accident or Damage Reported

Personal Use

3+ Owners

34 Service History Records

Used 2019 Ford Escape SEL

$9,995 | 92,879 miles

great value

Accident/Minor Damage

Personal Use

2-Owner

32 Service History Records

Used 2012 Jeep Wrangler Sport

$8,995 | 133,968 miles

great value

No Accident or Damage Reported

Personal Use

3+ Owners

30 Service History Records

Used 2017 Jeep Grand Cherokee Limited Edition

$11,995 | 108,337 miles

great value

Accident/Minor Damage

Personal Use

3+ Owners

31 Service History Records

Used 2018 Chevrolet Traverse LT

$12,695 | 133,140 miles

good value

Minor Damage

Personal Use

CARFAX 1-Owner

23 Service History Records

Used 2017 Subaru Crosstrek Limited

$10,695 | 123,860 miles

great value

Odometer Rollback

Personal Use

3+ Owners

29 Service History Records

Used 2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i

$9,995 | 119,839 miles

good value

No Accident or Damage Reported

Personal Use

2-Owner

33 Service History Records

Used 2017 Hyundai Accent SE

$5,195 | 146,375 miles

great value

No Accident or Damage Reported

Personal Use

3+ Owners

12 Service History Records

Used 2011 Cadillac CTS Premium

$6,995 | 135,655 miles

great value

Minor Damage

Personal Use

CARFAX 1-Owner

24 Service History Records

Used 2022 Mitsubishi Eclipse Cross SE

$14,495 | 70,415 miles

great value

Accident Reported

Personal Use

CARFAX 1-Owner

7 Service History Records

1 - 12 of 32 results

Overall Rating

4.3

11 Verified Reviews

5 Star

73%

4 Star

3 Star

2 Star

1 Star

by Gail V. on 10/11/2025Verified Shopper

I found them helpful and understanding. They listen to what I wanted and answered my questions thoroughly. I highly recommend them for a used/pre owned vehicle.

by Lisa J. on 03/22/2025Verified Purchase

I thought they were friendly and professional. I was a bit surprised when I found out how much pmts would be monthly. I thought it would be cheaper based on a 5 yr loan. The best they could do was 2 yrs. There is a silver lining. The car will be payed off quicker. It was an overall good experience and I'm very happy with my Suburu .

by 2016 AUDI Q5 PREMIUM Shopper on 09/01/2021Verified Purchase

I purchased a 2011 Honda Pilot from this dealership. The drive from Long Island was worth it as they had the lowest price on what I was looking for. They're a no-nonsense dealership without hidden fees etc.. unlike others I've dealt with in the past. They had a descent inventory and I'll come back for my next vehicle.

by 2012 FORD ESCAPE LIMITED Shopper on 06/24/2021Verified Shopper

this is not a reputable dealer. I set up appointment to see car I e-mailed about.when i got there he sold the car out from under me. I will not deal with them again.people should look closely before dealing with them.

by Douglas on 07/26/2021

My name is Doug and I am the owner here at First Choice Auto. Please accept my sincere apologies for your recent negative experience. Im sorry to hear you were less than satisfied with your experience. Our goal is always the total satisfaction of our customers. Its always an unpleasant experience to inform anyone a vehicle has sold however the only fair way to offer vehicles is on a first come fist to purchase basis. Id like to discuss what occurred and how we might make it up to you. At your convenience, please contact me directly at 845-350-2086. We value our customers opinions, and thank you for bringing your concerns to our attention. Respectfully, Doug

by Kevin N. on 12/07/2020Verified Shopper

I offered a 15% down payment, but I got denied and they wanted a 38% down payment. I got a refund, but had to wait 20 days to get my money back

by 2006 TOYOTA HIGHLANDER LIMITED Shopper on 07/13/2022Verified Purchase

They were very helpful and had quality inventory.

by 2009 VOLKSWAGEN ROUTAN SEL Shopper on 03/08/2022Verified Purchase

Everything nice. The dealer call very fast

by 2014 DODGE DURANGO LIMITED Shopper on 12/26/2021Verified Shopper

Great dealership Very friendly

by Vilma O. on 08/10/2020Verified Purchase

Mr. Jones, he was super friendly, an excellent place, thank you, we were able to buy the car

by Hazel V. on 02/04/2020Verified Purchase

They are very helpful when we purchase a car. Thank you.

by Joshua B. on 01/08/2020Verified Shopper

They responded promptly and were very helpful

1 - 11 of 11 results

Get In Touch

Sales Information

Used Car Sales: (845) 622-5816

Today: Closed until 10:00 AM

Sunday

Closed

Monday

10:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Tuesday

10:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Wednesday

10:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Thursday

10:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Friday

10:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Saturday

11:00 AM - 4:00 PM

(Call for Appointment)

1544 Route 22 Wingdale, NY 12594

Frequently Asked Questions

What do verified customers think about First Choice Auto in Wingdale, NY?

Verified customers who visit First Choice Auto in Wingdale, NY rate this business 4.3 out of 5 stars, with 11 reviews.

How can I contact First Choice Auto in Wingdale, NY?

To reach the sales team at First Choice Auto in Wingdale, NY, call (845) 622-5816

Call

First Choice Auto

32 New and Used Vehicles for Sale at First Choice Auto

Ratings & Reviews

About Us

Frequently Asked Questions