Loading cars...

Top 5 Rated Used Cars

Carfax Advantage Dealer Logo
Open Now9:00am - 5:00pm
809 S Meadow St
Ithaca, NY 14850
Map & Directions
Open Now 9:00am - 5:00pm
Show Full Business Hours
Monday9:00am - 5:00pm
Tuesday9:00am - 5:00pm
Wednesday9:00am - 5:00pm
Thursday9:00am - 5:00pm
Friday9:00am - 5:00pm
Saturday9:00am - 5:00pm
Sunday9:00am - 5:00pm
Hide Business Hours

27 Used Vehicles Available at Top 5 Rated Used Cars

6 Photos
$11,995
great Value
$196/mo est.
$2,305 below
$14,300 CARFAX Value
2010 Lexus ES 350110,000 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Navigation System,Power Sun/Moonroof More
Color: Blue
Lexus Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 11/20/09 and owned in NY until 03/25/17.

  • Personal Use

    Driven an estimated 14,970 miles/year.

  • Service History

    No service history reported on this vehicle.

7 Photos
$10,495
great Value
$172/mo est.
$905 below
$11,400 CARFAX Value
2008 Toyota RAV4 Limited Edition94,000 miles
Popular Options- More
Color: Blue
Toyota Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • 2-Owner

    1st owner purchased on 11/29/07 and owned in NY until 10/23/12 • ...

  • Personal Use

    1st owner drove an estimated 12,178 miles/year • 2nd owner drove ...

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 68,697 miles in Yorkville, NY on 10/25/13 • Tire...

5 Photos
$7,995
great Value
$131/mo est.
$1,605 below
$9,600 CARFAX Value
2009 Subaru Outback 2.5i109,000 miles
Popular Options- More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • 3+ Owners

    1st owner purchased on 03/21/09 and owned in NY until 07/10/12 • ...

  • Personal Use

    1st owner drove an estimated 12,482 miles/year • 2nd owner drove ...

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 82,952 miles in Oneonta, NY on 05/14/14 • Vehicl...

6 Photos
$6,995
good Value
$115/mo est.
$245 below
$7,240 CARFAX Value
2007 Toyota Yaris Unspecified64,000 miles
Popular Options- More
Color: Blue
Toyota Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • 3+ Owners

    1st owner purchased on 03/24/07 and owned in FL until 04/22/10 • ...

  • Personal Use

    1st owner drove an estimated 0 miles/year • 2nd owner drove an es...

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 55,889 miles in Ithaca, NY on 05/15/15 • Spiral ...

7 Photos
$8,995
good Value
$147/mo est.
$435 below
$9,430 CARFAX Value
2012 Toyota Prius c Unspecified71,000 miles
Popular Options- More
Color: Blue
Toyota Certified Pre-Owned
  • Accident/ Damage

    Accident/Damage reported on this vehicle.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 08/07/12 and owned in NY until 12/15/16.

  • Personal Use

    Driven an estimated 16,395 miles/year.

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 71,510 miles in Syracuse, NY on 12/16/16 • Washe...

7 Photos
$10,495
good Value
$172/mo est.
$295 below
$10,790 CARFAX Value
2009 Subaru Forester 2.5X82,000 miles
Popular Options- More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • 2-Owner

    1st owner purchased on 05/24/08 and owned in PA until 03/28/17 • ...

  • Personal Use

    1st owner drove an estimated 9,260 miles/year • 2nd owner drove a...

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 59,444 miles in Mansfield, PA on 09/22/14 • Vehi...

6 Photos
$8,995
good Value
$147/mo est.
$605 below
$9,600 CARFAX Value
2007 Lexus IS 250N/A miles
Popular Options- Power Sun/Moonroof More
Color: Blue
Lexus Certified Pre-Owned
  • Accident/ Damage

    Accident/Damage reported on this vehicle.

  • 3+ Owners

    1st owner purchased on 07/20/07 and owned in NY until 04/26/10 • ...

  • Personal Use

    1st owner drove an estimated 3,523 miles/year • 2nd owner drove a...

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 106,000 miles in Johnstown, NY on 03/09/16 • Flu...

5 Photos
$5,995
good Value
$98/mo est.
$245 below
$6,240 CARFAX Value
2006 Pontiac Vibe Unspecified77,000 miles
Popular Options- More
Color: Blue
Pontiac Certified Pre-Owned
  • Accident/ Damage

    Accident/Damage reported on this vehicle.

  • 2-Owner

    1st owner purchased on 07/25/07 and owned in VT until 03/16/09 • ...

  • Personal Use

    1st owner drove an estimated 18,495 miles/year • 2nd owner drove ...

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 5,198 miles in Saint Johnsbury, VT on 11/17/07 •...

7 Photos
$5,995
good Value
$98/mo est.
$205 below
$6,200 CARFAX Value
2009 Nissan Versa Unspecified78,000 miles
Popular Options- More
Color: Blue
Nissan Certified Pre-Owned
  • Minor Damage

    Minor damage reported on this vehicle.

  • 3+ Owners

    1st owner purchased on 08/31/08 and owned in CT until 10/03/10 • ...

  • Personal Use

    1st owner drove an estimated 11,808 miles/year • 2nd owner drove ...

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 78,330 miles in Cortland, NY on 08/16/16 • Vehic...

7 Photos
$7,495
fair Value
$123/mo est.
$125 above
$7,370 CARFAX Value
2012 Nissan Sentra Unspecified83,000 miles
Popular Options- More
Color: Blue
Nissan Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • 2-Owner

    1st owner purchased on 10/10/11 and owned in NY until 07/24/12 • ...

  • Multiple Use

    1st owner drove an estimated 0 miles/year • 2nd owner drove an es...

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 81,000 miles in Binghamton, NY on 09/25/15 • Mai...

6 Photos
$7,495
fair Value
$123/mo est.
$315 above
$7,180 CARFAX Value
2010 Hyundai Elantra Unspecified48,000 miles
Popular Options- More
Color: Blue
Hyundai Certified Pre-Owned
  • Accident/ Damage

    Accident/Damage reported on this vehicle.

  • 2-Owner

    1st owner purchased on 08/09/10 and owned in NJ until 01/04/16 • ...

  • Personal Use

    1st owner drove an estimated 8,770 miles/year • 2nd owner drove a...

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 43,525 miles in Jersey City, NJ on 09/06/13 • Ma...

7 Photos
$10,995
fair Value
$180/mo est.
$315 above
$10,680 CARFAX Value
2010 Toyota Prius Unspecified79,000 miles
Popular Options- More
Color: Blue
Toyota Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • 2-Owner

    1st owner purchased on 05/14/10 and owned in NY until 05/14/13 • ...

  • Multiple Use

    1st owner drove an estimated 12,352 miles/year • 2nd owner drove ...

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 79,807 miles in Oneonta, NY on 03/17/17 • Four t...

7 Photos
$7,995
fair Value
$131/mo est.
$395 above
$7,600 CARFAX Value
2010 Nissan Sentra S56,000 miles
Popular Options- More
Color: Blue
Nissan Certified Pre-Owned
  • Accident/ Damage

    Accident/Damage reported on this vehicle.

  • 2-Owner

    1st owner purchased on 05/17/10 and owned in NY until 07/02/12 • ...

  • Personal Use

    1st owner drove an estimated 3,614 miles/year • 2nd owner drove a...

  • Service History

    No service history reported on this vehicle.

$8,995
good Value
$147/mo est.
$455 below
$9,450 CARFAX Value
2009 Toyota Camry Unspecified88,000 miles
Popular Options- More
Color: Blue
Toyota Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 08/16/08 and owned in PA until 02/14/17.

  • Personal Use

    Driven an estimated 10,464 miles/year.

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 88,385 miles in Pittsburgh, PA on 01/24/17 • Mai...

5 Photos
$5,995
Value
$98/mo est.
$725 above
$5,270 CARFAX Value
2003 Toyota Corolla Unspecified105,000 miles
Popular Options- More
Color: Blue
Toyota Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • 2-Owner

    1st owner purchased on 06/18/02 and owned in NY until 02/13/15 • ...

  • Personal Use

    1st owner drove an estimated 6,063 miles/year • 2nd owner drove a...

  • Service History

    Last serviced in Elmira, NY on 07/14/11 • Maintenance inspection ...

7 Photos
$8,995
Value
$147/mo est.
$655 above
$8,340 CARFAX Value
2009 Honda Fit Sport61,000 miles
Popular Options- More
Color: Blue
Honda Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • 2-Owner

    1st owner purchased on 11/06/08 and owned in NY until 02/17/10 • ...

  • Personal Use

    1st owner drove an estimated 13,951 miles/year • 2nd owner drove ...

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 54,876 miles in Syracuse, NY on 11/24/15 • Exhau...

6 Photos
$6,995
Value
$115/mo est.
$585 above
$6,410 CARFAX Value
2012 Hyundai Accent GS90,000 miles
Popular Options- More
Color: Blue
Hyundai Certified Pre-Owned
  • Accident/ Damage

    Accident/Damage reported on this vehicle.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 11/25/11 and owned in NY until 02/24/17.

  • Personal Use

    Driven an estimated 16,880 miles/year.

  • Service History

    Last serviced in Yorkville, NY on 08/10/15 • Interior trim checke...

7 Photos
$8,995
Value
$147/mo est.
$695 above
$8,300 CARFAX Value
2011 Kia Optima LX68,000 miles
Popular Options- Satellite Radio More
Color: Blue
Kia Certified Pre-Owned
  • Accident/ Damage

    Accident/Damage reported on this vehicle.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 06/29/11 and owned in NY until 02/20/17.

  • Personal Use

    Driven an estimated 11,874 miles/year.

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 68,125 miles in Rochester, NY on 02/22/17 • Vehi...

5 Photos
$5,995
Value
$98/mo est.
$615 above
$5,380 CARFAX Value
2003 Toyota Corolla Unspecified98,000 miles
Popular Options- More
Color: Blue
Toyota Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • 3+ Owners

    1st owner purchased on 05/02/03 and owned in IL until 11/04/05 • ...

  • Personal Use

    1st owner drove an estimated 4,823 miles/year • 2nd owner drove a...

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 65,576 miles in Cazenovia, NY on 05/05/14 • Anti...

6 Photos
$7,495
Value
$123/mo est.
$945 above
$6,550 CARFAX Value
2010 Hyundai Elantra Unspecified64,000 miles
Popular Options- More
Color: Blue
Hyundai Certified Pre-Owned
  • Accident/ Damage

    Accident/Damage reported on this vehicle.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 08/24/10 and owned in NY until 05/22/15.

  • Personal Use

    Driven an estimated 14,208 miles/year.

  • Service History

    Last serviced in Baldwin, NY on 04/28/13 • Oil and filter changed...

6 Photos
$10,495
Value
$172/mo est.
$1,795 above
$8,700 CARFAX Value
2013 Toyota Matrix L63,000 miles
Popular Options- More
Color: Blue
Toyota Certified Pre-Owned
  • Accident/ Damage

    Accident/Damage reported on this vehicle.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 10/28/13 and owned in NY until 02/10/17.

  • Commercial Use

    Driven an estimated 19,325 miles/year.

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 45,250 miles in Greenville, SC on 02/18/16 • Oil...

7 Photos
$5,995
Value
$98/mo est.
$575 above
$5,420 CARFAX Value
2009 Nissan Versa Unspecified77,000 miles
Popular Options- More
Color: Blue
Nissan Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • 3+ Owners

    1st owner purchased on 08/20/09 and owned in MA until 11/30/09 • ...

  • Multiple Use

    1st owner drove an estimated 0 miles/year • 2nd owner drove an es...

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 74,799 miles in Horseheads, NY on 07/19/16 • Veh...

6 Photos
$12,995
Value
$213/mo est.
$1,775 above
$11,220 CARFAX Value
2010 Subaru Forester 2.5X81,000 miles
Popular Options- Power Sun/Moonroof More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • Accident/ Damage

    Accident/Damage reported on this vehicle.

  • 3+ Owners

    1st owner purchased on 04/30/10 and owned in NY until 07/25/13 • ...

  • Personal Use

    1st owner drove an estimated 11,463 miles/year • 2nd owner drove ...

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 76,898 miles in Binghamton, NY on 05/29/16 • Air...

7 Photos
$6,995
Value
$115/mo est.
$2,095 above
$4,900 CARFAX Value
2007 Honda Fit Sport116,000 miles
Popular Options- Remote Start More
Color: Blue
Honda Certified Pre-Owned
  • Accident/ Damage

    Accident/Damage reported on this vehicle.

  • 2-Owner

    1st owner purchased on 08/03/06 and owned in NY until 01/07/13 • ...

  • Personal Use

    1st owner drove an estimated 10,657 miles/year • 2nd owner drove ...

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 108,275 miles in Vestal, NY on 04/11/16 • Four w...

6 Photos
$9,995
Value
$164/mo est.
$805 above
$9,190 CARFAX Value
2009 Subaru Outback 2.5i94,000 miles
Popular Options- More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • Accident/ Damage

    Accident/Damage reported on this vehicle.

  • 3+ Owners

    1st owner purchased on 04/08/09 and owned in NH until 11/23/09 • ...

  • Multiple Use

    1st owner drove an estimated 0 miles/year • 2nd owner drove an es...

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 56,019 miles in Oneonta, NY on 08/29/14 • Wheels...

Displaying 25 of 27 results

Sign in to your CARFAX Account

Sign in to your CARFAX Account
Forgot Password

Sign up for your CARFAX Account

Create CARFAX Account
Already a member? Login Here

Save This Search

Email me price drops and new listings for this search!
Create CARFAX Account
Already a member? Login Here

Follow this car

Email me if this and similar cars drop in price or become newly available!
0 miles0
Create CARFAX Account
Already a member? Login Here

Send to my Phone

0 miles0

Listing sent to:

Email Listing

0 miles0
Add a personal note(optional)
Your message was sent!