Loading cars...

Johnstons Subaru

Carfax Advantage Dealer Logo
Open Now9:00am - 5:00pm
243 Dolson Ave
Middletown, NY 10940
Map & Directions
Open Now 9:00am - 5:00pm
Show Full Business Hours
Monday9:00am - 5:00pm
Tuesday9:00am - 5:00pm
Wednesday9:00am - 5:00pm
Thursday9:00am - 5:00pm
Friday9:00am - 5:00pm
Saturday9:00am - 5:00pm
Sunday9:00am - 5:00pm
Hide Business Hours

93 Used Vehicles Available at Johnstons Subaru

26 Photos
$19,990
great Value
$327/mo est.
$1,560 below
$21,550 CARFAX Value
2014 Subaru Outback 2.5i37,704 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Heated Seats,Keyless Entry,Fog Lights,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 11/07/13 and owned in NY until 12/14/16.

  • Personal Use

    Driven an estimated 12,146 miles/year.

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 37,719 miles in Middletown, NY on 12/31/16 • Fog...

26 Photos
$23,900
great Value
$391/mo est.
$1,930 below
$25,830 CARFAX Value
2015 Subaru Forester 2.0XT22,792 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Heated Seats,Keyless Entry,Power Sun/Moonroof,Rear-View Camera,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 05/14/15 and owned in NY until 03/31/17.

  • Personal Use

    Driven an estimated 12,109 miles/year.

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 0 miles in Middletown, NY on 04/05/17 • Pre-deli...

26 Photos
$21,990
great Value
$360/mo est.
$2,530 below
$24,520 CARFAX Value
2015 Subaru Outback 2.5i40,422 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Satellite Radio,Heated Seats,Keyless Entry,Fog Lights,Rear-View Camera,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 04/17/15 and owned in NY until 03/28/17.

  • Personal Use

    Driven an estimated 20,155 miles/year.

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 0 miles in Middletown, NY on 04/07/17 • Washed/d...

26 Photos
$15,900
great Value
$260/mo est.
$2,280 below
$18,180 CARFAX Value
2014 Subaru Impreza Sport60,898 miles
Popular Options- Heated Seats,Tire Pressure Monitoring System,Leather Seats,Fog Lights,Leather Trimmed Interior,Rear-View Camera,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 09/16/14 and owned in NY until 03/10/17.

  • Personal Use

    Driven an estimated 24,533 miles/year.

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 0 miles in Middletown, NY on 03/16/17 • Pre-deli...

26 Photos
$21,990
great Value
$360/mo est.
$1,090 below
$23,080 CARFAX Value
2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i19,283 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Keyless Entry,Power Sun/Moonroof,Rear-View Camera,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 11/28/14 and owned in NY until 08/11/16.

  • Personal Use

    Driven an estimated 11,208 miles/year.

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 19,300 miles in Middletown, NY on 12/27/16 • Wip...

26 Photos
$16,990
great Value
$278/mo est.
$1,200 below
$18,190 CARFAX Value
2014 Subaru Forester 2.5i72,702 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Keyless Entry,Power Sun/Moonroof,Rear-View Camera,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 01/31/14 and owned in NY until 01/31/17.

  • Personal Use

    Driven an estimated 24,211 miles/year.

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 0 miles in Middletown, NY on 04/10/17 • Drive be...

26 Photos
$15,990
great Value
$262/mo est.
$1,020 below
$17,010 CARFAX Value
2015 Subaru Impreza Unspecified34,367 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Keyless Entry,Rear-View Camera,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 03/05/15 and owned in NY until 02/21/17.

  • Personal Use

    Driven an estimated 16,928 miles/year.

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 0 miles in Middletown, NY on 03/10/17 • Washed/d...

26 Photos
$13,990
great Value
$229/mo est.
$860 below
$14,850 CARFAX Value
2013 Subaru Impreza Unspecified62,278 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Keyless Entry,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 05/21/13 and owned in PA until 04/10/17.

  • Personal Use

    Driven an estimated 16,008 miles/year.

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 0 miles in Milford, PA on 04/04/17 • Vehicle ser...

26 Photos
$22,490
great Value
$368/mo est.
$1,290 below
$23,780 CARFAX Value
2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i10,262 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Keyless Entry,Power Sun/Moonroof,Rear-View Camera,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 01/23/15 and owned in NY until 11/17/16.

  • Personal Use

    Driven an estimated 5,641 miles/year.

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 10,262 miles in Middletown, NY on 11/17/16 • Pre...

26 Photos
$20,990
great Value
$344/mo est.
$4,070 below
$25,060 CARFAX Value
2014 Subaru Forester 2.5i48,729 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Heated Seats,Leather Seats,Keyless Entry,Fog Lights,Power Sun/Moonroof,Leather Trimmed Interior,Rear-View Camera,Trip ... More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 04/10/14 and owned in PA until 12/28/16.

  • Personal Use

    Driven an estimated 2 miles/year.

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 0 miles in Middletown, NY on 02/20/17 • Pre-deli...

25 Photos
$16,990
great Value
$278/mo est.
$1,200 below
$18,190 CARFAX Value
2015 Subaru Legacy 2.5i50,015 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Keyless Entry,Rear-View Camera More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 10/17/14 and owned in NY until 11/21/16.

  • Personal Use

    Driven an estimated 26,189 miles/year.

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 0 miles in Middletown, NY on 04/11/17 • Vehicle ...

26 Photos
$17,990
great Value
$295/mo est.
$1,660 below
$19,650 CARFAX Value
2016 Subaru Impreza Unspecified12,379 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Heated Seats,Keyless Entry,Rear-View Camera,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 03/14/16 and owned in SD until 02/20/17.

  • Rental Use

    Driven an estimated 13,172 miles/year.

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 12,380 miles in Middletown, NY on 04/18/17 • Veh...

26 Photos
$24,990
great Value
$409/mo est.
$1,510 below
$26,500 CARFAX Value
2016 Subaru Outback 2.5i13,757 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Heated Seats,Keyless Entry,Fog Lights,Rear-View Camera,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 05/05/16 and owned in OH until 02/20/17.

  • Rental Use

    Rental vehicle

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 0 miles in Middletown, NY on 03/01/17 • Pre-deli...

26 Photos
$24,990
great Value
$409/mo est.
$1,410 below
$26,400 CARFAX Value
2016 Subaru Outback 2.5i11,241 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Heated Seats,Keyless Entry,Fog Lights,Rear-View Camera,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 05/05/16 and owned in IL until 02/20/17.

  • Rental Use

    Rental vehicle

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 0 miles in Middletown, NY on 04/07/17 • Washed/d...

26 Photos
$17,990
great Value
$295/mo est.
$1,640 below
$19,630 CARFAX Value
2016 Subaru Impreza Unspecified8,186 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Heated Seats,Keyless Entry,Rear-View Camera,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 05/18/16 and owned in IL until 01/09/17.

  • Rental Use

    Rental vehicle

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 0 miles in Middletown, NY on 01/14/17 • Pre-deli...

26 Photos
$17,990
great Value
$295/mo est.
$1,560 below
$19,550 CARFAX Value
2016 Subaru Impreza Unspecified9,443 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Heated Seats,Keyless Entry,Rear-View Camera,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 04/22/16 and owned in IL until 01/02/17.

  • Rental Use

    Rental vehicle

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 9,459 miles in Middletown, NY on 02/17/17 • Vehi...

26 Photos
$25,990
great Value
$426/mo est.
$1,710 below
$27,700 CARFAX Value
2016 Subaru Outback 2.5i4,466 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Heated Seats,Keyless Entry,Fog Lights,Rear-View Camera,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 10/17/16 and owned in NY until 12/30/16.

  • Commercial Use

    Commercial Use vehicle

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 0 miles in Middletown, NY on 04/18/17 • Vehicle ...

26 Photos
$17,990
great Value
$295/mo est.
$1,440 below
$19,430 CARFAX Value
2016 Subaru Impreza Unspecified11,217 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Heated Seats,Keyless Entry,Rear-View Camera,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 04/29/16 and owned in IL until 01/02/17.

  • Rental Use

    Rental vehicle

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 0 miles in Middletown, NY on 01/07/17 • Pre-deli...

26 Photos
$23,900
great Value
$391/mo est.
$680 below
$24,580 CARFAX Value
2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i12,264 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Heated Seats,Keyless Entry,Power Sun/Moonroof,Rear-View Camera,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 05/09/16 and owned in NY until 02/27/17.

  • Rental Use

    Rental vehicle

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 12,260 miles in Middletown, NY on 03/03/17 • Pre...

26 Photos
$17,990
great Value
$295/mo est.
$1,370 below
$19,360 CARFAX Value
2016 Subaru Impreza Unspecified11,017 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Heated Seats,Keyless Entry,Rear-View Camera,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 04/14/16 and owned in SD until 01/02/17.

  • Rental Use

    Rental vehicle

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 0 miles in Middletown, NY on 01/07/17 • Pre-deli...

26 Photos
$24,990
great Value
$409/mo est.
$2,040 below
$27,030 CARFAX Value
2016 Subaru Outback 2.5i9,332 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Heated Seats,Keyless Entry,Fog Lights,Rear-View Camera,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 04/07/16 and owned in IL until 01/09/17.

  • Rental Use

    Rental vehicle

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 9,550 miles in Middletown, NY on 02/07/17 • Four...

26 Photos
$24,990
great Value
$409/mo est.
$1,770 below
$26,760 CARFAX Value
2016 Subaru Outback 2.5i8,624 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Heated Seats,Keyless Entry,Fog Lights,Rear-View Camera,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 06/14/16 and owned in IL until 02/20/17.

  • Rental Use

    Rental vehicle

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 0 miles in Middletown, NY on 03/01/17 • Pre-deli...

26 Photos
$23,990
great Value
$393/mo est.
$640 below
$24,630 CARFAX Value
2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i11,035 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Heated Seats,Keyless Entry,Power Sun/Moonroof,Rear-View Camera,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 05/09/16 and owned in NY until 02/27/17.

  • Rental Use

    Rental vehicle

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 0 miles in Middletown, NY on 03/03/17 • Pre-deli...

26 Photos
$17,990
great Value
$295/mo est.
$1,330 below
$19,320 CARFAX Value
2016 Subaru Impreza Unspecified12,530 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Heated Seats,Keyless Entry,Rear-View Camera,Trip Computer More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • No Accidents Reported

    No accidents reported to CARFAX.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 03/22/16 and owned in IL until 02/20/17.

  • Rental Use

    Driven an estimated 13,652 miles/year.

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 0 miles in Middletown, NY on 03/01/17 • Pre-deli...

26 Photos
$22,990
great Value
$376/mo est.
$500 below
$23,490 CARFAX Value
2015 Subaru WRX Unspecified60,212 miles
Popular Options- Handsfree/Bluetooth Integration,Heated Seats,Leather Seats,Keyless Entry,Fog Lights,Power Sun/Moonroof,Leather Trimmed Interior,Rear-View Camera,Trip ... More
Color: Blue
Subaru Certified Pre-Owned
  • Accident/ Damage

    Accident/Damage reported on this vehicle.

  • CARFAX 1-Owner

    Purchased on 07/15/14 and owned in NY until 01/31/17.

  • Personal Use

    Driven an estimated 23,606 miles/year.

  • Service History

    Last serviced at 0 miles in Middletown, NY on 04/08/17 • Vehicle ...

Displaying 25 of 93 results

Sign in to your CARFAX Account

Sign in to your CARFAX Account
Forgot Password

Sign up for your CARFAX Account

Create CARFAX Account
Already a member? Login Here

Save This Search

Email me price drops and new listings for this search!
Create CARFAX Account
Already a member? Login Here

Follow this car

Email me if this and similar cars drop in price or become newly available!
0 miles0
Create CARFAX Account
Already a member? Login Here

Send to my Phone

0 miles0

Directions sent to:

Email Listing

0 miles0
Add a personal note(optional)
Your message was sent!